Selah
Active Member
Yes, but the elect’s ministry as well. We were chosen for a purpose.Paul's ministry.
Yes, but the elect’s ministry as well. We were chosen for a purpose.Paul's ministry.
I guess you could say that...but it's really adding, but OK.Yes, but the elect’s ministry as well. We were chosen for a purpose.
See?I guess you could say that...but it's really adding, but OK.
God has given to each of us a ministry....that of proclaiming His word and spreading it to a lost world...
and also to debate between ourselves !
But, yes, 2 Timothy 1:12 is Paul referring to the work that God has given to him...
his missionary work to the Gentiles.
God can complete what He has trusted Paul to do.
When in doubt,,,check out the Common English Bible.
It's easier than checking out the Greek and it's always right.
(so far!).
Agreed Selah.See?
1 Peter 2:9 (NKJV) But you [are] a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, His own special people, that you may proclaim the praises of Him who called you out of darkness into His marvelous light;
Abide in Christ is where it's at.I agree.
God bless you Blessed.
Stay close to God and He'll never abandon you.
'night.
Was going to shut down, but wanted to comment on the above.....Lol … I sound like a Calvinist! Yikes!
Good night. Stay safe. Don't let the bed bugs bite.Was going to shut down, but wanted to comment on the above.....
You posted this because you had just said.
"Yes, but the elect’s ministry as well. We were chosen for a purpose."
Actually, Selah, every Christian believes that we are chosen for a purpose.
The NT does speak about election and it does speak about predestination.
Just not how Calvinists understand it.
God doesn't choose who will be saved or lost.....(that would be unjust and God cannot be unjust)...
but we are chosen for purpose...just like you stated.
So the predestination is always for:
HOW...METHOD
or
WHY....PURPOSE.
So maybe you sounded like a calvinist....
but you weren't wrong!
'night.
Abide in Christ is where it's at.
Agreed.To “abide” is to live, continue, or remain; so, to abide in Christ is to live in Him or remain in Him. When a person is saved, he or she is described as being “in Christ” (Romans 8:1; 2 Corinthians 5:17), held secure in a permanent relationship (John 10:28–29). Therefore, abiding in Christ is not a special level of Christian experience, rather, it is the position of all true believers. The difference between those abiding in Christ and those not abiding in Christ is the difference between the saved and the unsaved.
Right.Abiding in Christ is taught in 1 John 2:5–6, where it is synonymous with “knowing” Christ (verses 2 and 3). Later in the same chapter, John equates “remaining” in the Father and the Son with having the promise of eternal life (verses 24 and 25). Biblically, “abiding in,” “remaining in,” and “knowing” Christ are references to the same thing: salvation.
John 15:1-6 happens to be one of the most important scriptures in the NT, IMO.The phrase abiding in Christ pictures an intimate, close relationship, and not just a superficial acquaintance. In John 15:4–7, Jesus tells His disciples that drawing life from Him is essential, using the picture of branches united to a vine: “Abide in Me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself unless it abides in the vine, so neither can you unless you abide in Me. I am the vine, you are the branches; he who abides in Me and I in him, he bears much fruit, for apart from Me you can do nothing. If anyone does not abide in Me, he is thrown away as a branch and dries up; and they gather them, and cast them into the fire and they are burned. If you abide in Me, and My words abide in you, ask whatever you wish, and it will be done for you.” Without that vital union with Christ that salvation provides, there can be no life and no productivity. Elsewhere, the Bible likens our relationship with Christ to that of a body with a head (Colossians 1:18)—another essential union.
This sounds rather silly.Some people take the warning of John 15:6 (branches that do not abide in the vine are thrown away and burned) to mean that Christians are always in danger of losing their salvation. In other words, they say it’s possible to be saved but not “abide,”
LOLin which case we would be cast away. But this could only be true if “abiding” were separate from salvation, referring to a state of intimacy with Christ we must strive to attain post-salvation. The Bible is clear that salvation comes by grace and is maintained by grace (Galatians 3:2–3). Also, if a branch could somehow fall away from the vine, resulting in the loss of salvation, then other, very clear passages of Scripture would be contradicted (see John 10:27–30).
This is not possible Blessed.It is best to interpret the True Vine metaphor this way: Jesus is the True Vine, obviously. The branches who “abide” in Him are the truly saved—they have a real and vital connection to the Savior. The withered branches who do not “abide” in Him are the unsaved pretenders who feigned an attachment to the Vine but drew no life from Him.
This is the verse that is always used.In the end, the pretenders will be seen for what they were: hangers-on who had no authentic attachment to Jesus. For a while, both Peter and Judas seemed identical in their walk with Christ. But Peter was attached to the Vine; Judas was not.
John restates the withered-branch principle this way: “They [people now opposed to Christ] went out from us, but they did not really belong to us. For if they had belonged to us, they would have remained with us; but their going showed that none of them belonged to us” (1 John 2:19).
You got this from QotQuestions?One of the proofs of salvation is perseverance, or sustained abiding in Christ. The saved will continue in their walk with Christ (see Revelation 2:26). That is, they will “abide” or remain in Him. God will complete His work in them (Philippians 1:6), and they will bring forth much fruit to the glory of God (John 15:5). Those who fall away, turn their backs on Christ, or fail to abide simply show their lack of saving faith. Abiding is not what saves us, but it is one of the signs of salvation.
Proofs of abiding in Christ (i.e., proofs that one is truly saved and not just pretending) include obedience to Christ’s commands (John 15:10; 1 John 3:24); following Jesus’ example (1 John 2:6); living free from habitual sin (1 John 3:6); and the awareness of a divine presence within one’s life (1 John 4:13).
Got?
Just pointing out that an actual branch on a fruit tree or grape vine has no say so in its production of fruit. The vine nourishes the branches. If it never produced fruit it was never abiding. The abiding ones produce fruit.
Agreed.
But I don't see any "level" to Christianity.
One is either a Christian or they are not.
We can say that we're at different levels of understanding, but this has nothing to do with our salvation.
Right.
We have eternal life as long as we're abiding in Christ.
If we're living with God...we absolutely have eternal life.
John 15:1-6 happens to be one of the most important scriptures in the NT, IMO.
You've said a lot up there and I don't know if you care to keep discussing this....
IF we abide in Christ....we are always safe.
The branch that gets cut away, that is not producing fruit....is the branch that is not obeying God.
Now, the branch was IN THE VINE....it was attached to Jesus....the person is represens is a saved person.
The branch is cut away....because of not producing.
Producing what?
A life pleasing to God.
This does not mean that we have to be perfect because no one is.
Jesus said Only our Father in heaven is good.
God knows our faults and weaknesses.
But we must hang in there....
we must abide.
Agreed?
This sounds rather silly.
If we're abiding how could we not be saved?
If we're abiding we're IN CHRIST...
if we're IN CHRIST...we're saved.
Also, we're not in danger of losing our salvation at every turn.
Where would the joy be ?
The NT does teach, however, that some persons decide to leave the faith....
they decide they no longer want to serve God. These are the persons who could lose their salvation.
Also, some believe they could call themselves a Christian and then keep on living as before when they were lost...
this is wrong to. This is what repent means....to change direction.
The change could happen overnight - I've seen this - or it could take years...
justification is instantaneous...
sanctification is a process that is on-going.
LOL
The branch doesn't just fall away!
It WANTS to leave...
it disobeys God.
If God is disobeyed, just like Adam did,,,then of course we will not be abiding IN CHRIST.
WE will have abandoned HIM.
This is not possible Blessed.
How could any branch be a pretender?
If it was IN THE VINE....and the VINE GIVES LIFE...it was a saved branch/person.
Branches draw life from vines.
Jesus used this type of metaphor for a reason....
People back then grew grape to make wine...they knew what the metaphor means.
Why do we need to resort to this type of incorrect understanding?
Are we so afraid to displease God?
Are we so legalistic that we feel we need to be perfect?
I'm secure in Jesus.
As long as I WANT to be saved...
I will be saved.
This is the verse that is always used.
It's actually John stating that some of the persons following Jesus were some type of gnostics...those he called wolves in sheep's clothing.
We have to reconcile all scripture with other scripture.
It all has to agree.
You got this from QotQuestions?
It's a calvinist site and I don't care for it but sometimes the answers are really good.
I'd say that OSAS is not taught in the bible.....
I also don't understand why this should be a problem...
it's just Paul teaching us to stay close to God and to not deny Him so that He will not deny us.
I think we should be happy to know God and consider it a blessing and know that HE will never leave US.
Sorry for all the I's....
You can write back...I may not answer till tomorrow morning...
almost midnight here.
I been through this a few times and they say they are not a Calvinist site. If they were I think they would shout it from the rooftops. See Below.You got this from QotQuestions?
It's a calvinist site and I don't care for it but sometimes the answers are really good.
They are even on LOGOS now. Do a search on LOGOS for anything and they pop up a lot.I been through this a few times and they say they are not a Calvinist site. If they were I think they would shout it from the rooftops. See Below.
Welcome to GotQuestions.org, the flagship website of Got Questions Ministries, a network of sites with a shared mission: to glorify God and reach people for Christ by providing biblical answers to spiritually related questions.
We are Christian, evangelical, theologically conservative, and nondenominational. As a parachurch ministry, our purpose is to come alongside the Church, joining in the Great Commission Jesus entrusted to His followers, by offering support and answers to those seeking clarity on spiritually related questions.
Whether you are seeking guidance, looking for answers, or are curious about spiritual matters, we are here to serve you, support you, and share the profound truths of God’s Word with you. Got questions? The Bible has answers. We’ll help you find them!
GotQuestions.org was launched in February of 2002. The past 20+ years are an amazing account of God exploding and amplifying GotQuestions.org into one of the most frequently visited Christian websites in the world. We are currently averaging 22,000,000 pageviews per month and have received over 2,500,000,000 pageviews in our history. Click here for more information about our history.
![]()
About GotQuestions.org
What is GotQuestions.org all about? What is the mission, purpose, and goal of Got Questions Ministries?www.gotquestions.org
Well said brother. A site well worth perusing from time to timeI been through this a few times and they say they are not a Calvinist site. If they were I think they would shout it from the rooftops. See Below.
Welcome to GotQuestions.org, the flagship website of Got Questions Ministries, a network of sites with a shared mission: to glorify God and reach people for Christ by providing biblical answers to spiritually related questions.
We are Christian, evangelical, theologically conservative, and nondenominational. As a parachurch ministry, our purpose is to come alongside the Church, joining in the Great Commission Jesus entrusted to His followers, by offering support and answers to those seeking clarity on spiritually related questions.
Whether you are seeking guidance, looking for answers, or are curious about spiritual matters, we are here to serve you, support you, and share the profound truths of God’s Word with you. Got questions? The Bible has answers. We’ll help you find them!
GotQuestions.org was launched in February of 2002. The past 20+ years are an amazing account of God exploding and amplifying GotQuestions.org into one of the most frequently visited Christian websites in the world. We are currently averaging 22,000,000 pageviews per month and have received over 2,500,000,000 pageviews in our history. Click here for more information about our history.
![]()
About GotQuestions.org
What is GotQuestions.org all about? What is the mission, purpose, and goal of Got Questions Ministries?www.gotquestions.org
If "apostacy" wasn't possible, there wouldn't be WARNINGS about it!!!From Remnant Radio
A good Q/A on all the problem passages. Were they really saved, were they carnal christians or were they tares ? They discuss the 3 different categories of those in the church who fall away.
Agreed.Just pointing out that an actual branch on a fruit tree or grape vine has no say so in its production of fruit. The vine nourishes the branches. If it never produced fruit it was never abiding. The abiding ones produce fruit.
A branch cannot give itself light
A branch cannot prune itself
A branch cannot pollinate its buds
A branch cannot prevent frost damage
A branch cannot nourish itself
A branch cannot control insects, diseases
This is also for @TobyI been through this a few times and they say they are not a Calvinist site. If they were I think they would shout it from the rooftops. See Below.
Welcome to GotQuestions.org, the flagship website of Got Questions Ministries, a network of sites with a shared mission: to glorify God and reach people for Christ by providing biblical answers to spiritually related questions.
We are Christian, evangelical, theologically conservative, and nondenominational. As a parachurch ministry, our purpose is to come alongside the Church, joining in the Great Commission Jesus entrusted to His followers, by offering support and answers to those seeking clarity on spiritually related questions.
Whether you are seeking guidance, looking for answers, or are curious about spiritual matters, we are here to serve you, support you, and share the profound truths of God’s Word with you. Got questions? The Bible has answers. We’ll help you find them!
GotQuestions.org was launched in February of 2002. The past 20+ years are an amazing account of God exploding and amplifying GotQuestions.org into one of the most frequently visited Christian websites in the world. We are currently averaging 22,000,000 pageviews per month and have received over 2,500,000,000 pageviews in our history. Click here for more information about our history.
![]()
About GotQuestions.org
What is GotQuestions.org all about? What is the mission, purpose, and goal of Got Questions Ministries?www.gotquestions.org
Greetings Fran, trust you got a good night of sleep, it does indeed help us to think much better, and to reason with others as we do here on the forum.Very interesting coming from someone that teaches that we are SO DEAD as to be unable to seek after God.
Fran, I think I have used Nehemiah 8:8 with you before, but in case I have not, then please consider:The word dead is not limited to being dead spiritually speaking which you are doing with Luke 15:24.
Luke 15:24
“For this my son was dead, and is alive again; he was lost, and is found. And they began to be merry.”
Please notice" "For this my son was dead, and is alive again". One is not born again, or made alive, and then lose that life and must be born once again, etc. But, one can be a child of God and sin and end up among the congregation of the dead, without the evidence of true spiritual life and just go through the motion of being a son of God, yet their heart is not right with God and need to repent and do their first work.
If dead always means spiritual death, then that would be very true, and that's not my personal opinion but Jesus' very own teaching, so be careful not to mock truth!So, IOW, we can't even believe what JESUS teaches!
Apparently, Jesus was UNABLE TO COMMUNICATE what He meant to say.
No Fran, I know well what I was doing, even though you do not, the problem is yours, not mine.James 5:20
You picked that one wrong RB.
Read it again and then come back and report.
Explained above!JESUS said the PS was become alive AGAIN....
this means he was ALIVE, DEAD AND THEN ALIVE AGAIN.
Absolutely!Not enjoying God's best?
Explained above.JAMES SAID the one getting the believer that has wandered off back will SAVE HIS SOUL FROM DEATH.