Men Do Have a Certain Work

Rockson

Well-known member
I've entitled my thread, "Men Do Have a Certain Work" that is for salvation but it's not a work seeking to be saved they the keeping of the law, but rather by an act of faith. That's the context of which Paul was speaking of in Eph 2:8 when talking about works.....not a work of faith but rather the work of seeking to be saved by the keeping of the law. You ARE NOT saved by such but you are saved by an act or yes (I won't back down from it) by a work of faith which WE DO and not God.

Yes I know many dear Calvinists will hunker down and persist in their false interpretation of Eph 2:8 "Not of works" part of a verse but I'd hope at least some of them will have a second look at what Jesus said about it and that in turn is what Paul meant about it too. Let's go to Jn 6:26,30 and I think I might be able to show a verse they've never given much consideration. Calvinists will look at Jn 6:29 and assert something in error about it and THEY WILL NOT look at the verses around it . I appeal however to Calvinists which are honest and sincere. Let's look at the 4 verses below, ALL OF THEM.

Jesus answered them, “Truly, truly, I say to you, you are seeking me, not because you saw signs, but because you ate your fill of the loaves. 27Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food that endures to eternal life, which the Son of Man will give to you. For on him God the Father has set his seal.” 28Then they said to him, “What must we do, to be doing the works of God?” 29Jesus answered them, “This is the work of God, that you believe in him whom he has sent.” 30So they said to him, “Then what sign do you do, that we may see and believe you? What work do you perform? Jn 6:26,30

Let's unpack this. Jesus told them THEY were working for something....THEY WERE! Not God They were working for the food which perishes but Jesus told them they were not to work for that which perishes BUT....BUT they were to work, YES WORK for a different thing......to work for the food which endures to eternal life which the Son of Man would give them which he would give them AFTER they worked......but that is the WORK OF FAITH they were to work.

Not the work of trying to be saved by the keeping of the law (which Paul spoke about) but rather the work of faith. They asked Jesus what was the work that THEY were to do? Jesus told them this was the work they were to do.....believe on the Son. They all knew what Jesus meant by that even his emeries! Not one of them could say what Jesus said wasn't clear!

Not one of them said, "Of well if God puts all the believing in us (as a Calvinist would say) then OK God if we're not believing it's your fault!" Not one of them said that! They basically replied to Jesus in verse 30, Ok you're saying WE MUST do a certain work.....and that work is to believe in you, for that is what you've said.....now what sign will you do so that we can, we can, WE CAN DO THIS WORK. Folks context is KING! The work of a person in believing is something THEY DO not God.
 
They were under the impression they could do a work that would save them. Jesus corrected them with "This is the work of God". There's no way to retranslate that as "this is the work God requires". It's the work of God: God's work.

They actually understood this at least a little bit, because they followed up with, "If it's the work of God, show us. Do some miraculous sign powered by God so that we can believe." They switched from "what work can we do" to "What work do YOU perform?"

28 Therefore they said to Him, “What shall we do, so that we may work the works of God?” 29 Jesus answered and said to them, “This is the work of God, that you believe in Him whom He has sent.” 30 So they said to Him, “What then do You do for a sign, so that we may see, and believe You? What work do You perform?
 
They were under the impression they could do a work that would save them.
They were under the impression they could do A CERTAIN WORK to save them for Jesus told them there was a certain work that could save them.

Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food that endures to eternal life, which the Son of Man will give to you. Jn 6:27

He told them they were to work, they were to work, they, they, they were to work for the food that endures to eternal life. That work is the work of FAITH that THEY were to do! How about stop trying to change that in saying that's not what it says.

Jesus corrected them with "This is the work of God".
Sorry but you forgot verse 27 which I quoted above. Please don't make me have to quote that again and again and again. Read my paragraphs above.

There's no way to retranslate that as "this is the work God requires".
All one has to do is read Jn 6:27 for what it says. This is the work that God requires is the ONLY WAY this can be interpreted.
It's the work of God: God's work.
Jn 6:27 is not the work of God it's the work of faith which men must do.
 
They actually understood this at least a little bit, because they followed up with, "If it's the work of God, show us. Do some miraculous sign powered by God so that we can believe
Well no not going to let you get away with that. They did not , DID NOT say "If it's the work of God" you implying that's what they said to change clear meanings. Here's what they said, "Then what sign do you do, that we may see and believe you? What work do you perform? Jn 6:26,30 So if WE ARE to do this work of believing what sign will you do to inspire us to believe. The work of believing...was theirs.




 
To be honest this thread is a little bit over my head, but that's a good thing as I'll study some and see if I can make heads or tail out of it.

If you don't mind all interject a little humor for the time being.

"Men Do Have a Certain Work" My wife would say, Yes they certainly do. Then pull out a big long list. And spring is almost here... I can hardly wait.
 
Sorry but you forgot verse 27 which I quoted above. Please don't make me have to quote that again and again and again. Read my paragraphs above.

As Jesus often did, he responded to the question with an answer they did not expect or understand. The fact that they were asking for what work they could do doesn't require Jesus to give them an answer about what work they could do. In fact, he said it was the work of God, not them.

Apparently you don't understand the answer, either.
 
As Jesus often did, he responded to the question with an answer they did not expect or understand. The fact that they were asking for what work they could do doesn't require Jesus to give them an answer about what work they could do. In fact, he said it was the work of God, not them.

Apparently you don't understand the answer, either.
No, no, no, no, NO. You're not quoting the first part of the passage! The crowd hadn't even asked him yet of ANYTHING. It was Jesus who said that THEY NEEDED.....they needed to do a certain work.

Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food Jn 6:27 that endures to eternal life,

They were to work, they were to work, they were to work for the food that endures for eternal life. That's.....what Jesus said.

It was Jesus statement which inspired them to ask the question....OK well if WE MUST work a certain work to attain eternal life than what is the work that WE ARE TO DO?????
He then told them. Their work was to believe him....not God's work! Their work! You would do well not to deny this.
 
They were under the impression they could do a work that would save them. Jesus corrected them with "This is the work of God". There's no way to retranslate that as "this is the work God requires". It's the work of God: God's work.

They actually understood this at least a little bit, because they followed up with, "If it's the work of God, show us. Do some miraculous sign powered by God so that we can believe." They switched from "what work can we do" to "What work do YOU perform?"

28 Therefore they said to Him, “What shall we do, so that we may work the works of God?” 29 Jesus answered and said to them, “This is the work of God, that you believe in Him whom He has sent.” 30 So they said to Him, “What then do You do for a sign, so that we may see, and believe You? What work do You perform?
What part of you must believe from the text don't you understand ?

John 6- Then Jesus declared, “I am the bread of life. Whoever comes to me will never go hungry, and whoever believes in me will never be thirsty. 36 But as I told you, you have seen me and still you do not believe. 47 Very truly I tell you, the one who believes has eternal life.
 
No, no, no, no, NO. You're not quoting the first part of the passage! The crowd hadn't even asked him yet of ANYTHING. It was Jesus who said that THEY NEEDED.....they needed to do a certain work.

Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food Jn 6:27 that endures to eternal life,

They were to work, they were to work, they were to work for the food that endures for eternal life. That's.....what Jesus said.

It was Jesus statement which inspired them to ask the question....OK well if WE MUST work a certain work to attain eternal life than what is the work that WE ARE TO DO?????
He then told them. Their work was to believe him....not God's work! Their work! You would do well not to deny this.

27 Do not work for food that spoils, but for food that endures to eternal life, which the Son of Man will give you.
 
27 Do not work for food that spoils, but for food that endures to eternal life, which the Son of Man will give you.
Yes making my clear point. Does nothing to make yours! We don't work for food that spoils but we work for that which doesn't spoil.....and because of that work of faith that we do YES THAT WE DO, you receive that which he will give us.....ETERNAL LIFE.

Any rational sincere individual is going to acknowledge that when he says BUT FOR, that connects to the statement prior.....it would be non sensical if it didn't So he's not saying that they're not to work but he's telling them they need to do a different type of work......the FAITH WORK....and they're to do it.....and in so doing the Lord will give them the eternal life. Now this is beyond even crystal clear. As I say I really would appeal to you and exhort you NOT to deny it.
 
Jesus corrected them with "This is the work of God". There's no way to retranslate that as "this is the work God requires". It's the work of God: God's work.
Actually, it is the most natural way of interpreting it. There is not contextual information that identifies a change of direction from the original question that was asked. Over and over again the Scriptures speak of our exercising faith and/or actively believing in Christ, which is precisely what Jesus was saying! The work or action God requires from us is faith in him.

You have to add an extra layer that is not evident in the immediate context, and this causes you to prove your point is true by assuming that it is true. That is circular reasoning.

Doug
 
Actually, it is the most natural way of interpreting it. There is not contextual information that identifies a change of direction from the original question that was asked. Over and over again the Scriptures speak of our exercising faith and/or actively believing in Christ, which is precisely what Jesus was saying! The work or action God requires from us is faith in him.

You have to add an extra layer that is not evident in the immediate context, and this causes you to prove your point is true by assuming that it is true. That is circular reasoning.

Doug
Exactly! He has no proof for his view and just assumes it
 
As Jesus often did, he responded to the question with an answer they did not expect or understand. The fact that they were asking for what work they could do doesn't require Jesus to give them an answer about what work they could do. In fact, he said it was the work of God, not them.

Apparently you don't understand the answer, either.
You have a major problem in that you present no evidence for your view

You simply assume it apart from context

Jesus told them to work

They ask what work must we do to work the works of God

Jesus told them this is the work of God that you believe on Christ

The Jews understand Christ to be telling them they have to believe and ask what sign will you give us that we might believe

Jesus continues by speaking of the necessity to believe

Never once does Jesus correct them to change his stance they are to do something

Never does he state they really need to passively receive the faith necessary to work the works of God
 
No, no, no, no, NO. You're not quoting the first part of the passage! The crowd hadn't even asked him yet of ANYTHING. It was Jesus who said that THEY NEEDED.....they needed to do a certain work.

Do not work for the food that perishes, but for the food Jn 6:27 that endures to eternal life,

They were to work, they were to work, they were to work for the food that endures for eternal life. That's.....what Jesus said.

It was Jesus statement which inspired them to ask the question....OK well if WE MUST work a certain work to attain eternal life than what is the work that WE ARE TO DO?????
He then told them. Their work was to believe him....not God's work! Their work! You would do well not to deny this.
Spot on brother- the work is ours to do. God requires it of us. Faith is mans responsibility.
 
You have a major problem in that you present no evidence for your view

You simply assume it apart from context

Jesus told them to work

They ask what work must we do to work the works of God

Jesus told them this is the work of God that you believe on Christ

The Jews understand Christ to be telling them they have to believe and ask what sign will you give us that we might believe

Jesus continues by speaking of the necessity to believe

Never once does Jesus correct them to change his stance they are to do something

Never does he state they really need to passively receive the faith necessary to work the works of God
They ask what work must we do to work the works of God ?

The correct answer is always to believe in the Son- that is the message of salvation throughout the entire N.T.

The calvinist contradicts the plain teaching of the entire N.T. by distorting a single verse in John 6 and twisting it to say the exact opposite.
 
They ask what work must we do to work the works of God ?

The correct answer is always to believe in the Son- that is the message of salvation throughout the entire N.T.

The calvinist contradicts the plain teaching of the entire N.T. by distorting a single verse in John 6 and twisting it to say the exact opposite.
Yes their theology rather than context drives their interpretation
 
As Jesus often did, he responded to the question with an answer they did not expect or understand. The fact that they were asking for what work they could do doesn't require Jesus to give them an answer about what work they could do. In fact, he said it was the work of God, not them.

Apparently you don't understand the answer, either.
And you do? Why not include yourself in this. You set the requirement to include yourself and then abandoned it. This is redefinition of a self serving theology. Why do you always act like you're different than everyone else?
 
As Jesus often did, he responded to the question with an answer they did not expect or understand. The fact that they were asking for what work they could do doesn't require Jesus to give them an answer about what work they could do. In fact, he said it was the work of God, not them.

Apparently you don't understand the answer, either.
Apparently you just wish to skip the fact Jesus did not correct them..Instead they are told over and over they must believe
 
Back
Top Bottom