Absolutely!!! Which "theory of the atonement" you happen to hang your hat on doesn't really mean SPIT (they're all nothing but "Theology" after all).
When I was Born Again, there wasn't any "Theology" involved. The Conviction of SIN by the Holy Spirit to me personally establish ed several things: I was a sinner, I was NOT going to "Make the cut" when Judgement (or death) came, and God's WORD (conviction) was my source of FAITH, that I'd be O.K. if I surrendered to HIM, repented, and cried out to HIM for salvation. NO "theology" needed.
There's plenty of time AFTER you're Born Again to confuse yourself with "Denominational theology". The Southern Baptists got to me first, and SOME of what they taught me has stood the test of time and experience, and some didn't. SO 60 years later, I'm a member in good standing of the Assemblies of God Denomination, whose theology I find acceptable for the most part, but which doesn't define me. The AG tends toward the PSA, but isn't comfortable with all its details