"Works Salvation"

the thief on the cross died with the New Covenant
Wrong.
How could he have died under the new covenant when Jesus had not even ressurected from the dead?
Hebrews 9:16-17,
- for where a testament is there must also of necessity be the DEATH of the testator
- for a testament is IN FORCE AFTER MEN ARE DEAD, otherwise it is of no strength WHILE THE TESTATOR LIVETH


Jesus saved the thief while He was still alive,
- today you will be with Me in paradise(saved while Jesus was alive)

Therefore Jesus' new testament had not yet gone into force.
Also to be saved under the new covenant you must believe in the death, burial and ressurection of Christ.
The thief had not even witnessed Jesus' ressurection.
Jesus never required the thief to believe the new testament gospel.
The thief died during the old law of Moses while it was still in force.
John the Baptist was baptizing Jews during this time. John's baptism is under the old law.
 
Did the thief on the cross next to JESUS come down from his cross, get water baptized, then back unto the cross to die

Obvious TRUTH = no need for the thief to be water baptized = the Blood of the New Covenant washed his sins away
The thief did not spend his entire life on the cross!!!
We dont know if he was or was not baptized by John before his crucifixion.
I will not speculate.
You have ASSUMED he was not baptized. You have zero scripture to back this up. So it is unscriptual man made reasoning.

The blood of the new covenant only washes away sins when one obeys Jesus' new testament gospel. Then and only then will Jesus' blood wash away sins.
Acts 22:16,
- and now why are you waiting Arise and be baptized and wash away your sins, calling on the name of the Lord

Paul had not called on the name of the Lord until he was baptized into Christ,
Galatians 3:26-27,
- for ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus
- for(Greek word gar meaning: heres the reason) as many of you as have been baptized INTO Christ have PUT ON Christ
 
Yes but more specifically works of the law of Moses.
I think Paul was referring to law, generally, where law refers to a code of conduct whereby one conducts and lives his life (See Romans 2:12-15)
Paul referred to these works that do not save as works where by if men could be saved by them, they would boast.
And well they should, since to be saved by works was possible only if the law was obeyed perfectly with not a single transgression. But, of course, as Paul noted, no one has. Actually, if one were to obey the law perfectly, they would not have any trespasses and sins that needed to be forgiven and therefore would have "earned" eternal life.
There are works in the gospel of Jesus Christ that are required by God, belief, repentance, public confession, water baptism, faithful living.
Those are not works of law, but rather obedience to the gospel.
But these works do not save by meriting salvation so doing these works, one has nothing to boast about.
I agree.
Do you believe Jesus' new testament gospel is law that we are under today?
No, as I noted above, I think law refers to that code of conduct by which we live. Hearing, belief, repentance, confession and baptism are not a part of a code of conduct. They are conditions to which God honors His promises to give eternal life, i.e, salvation. We are under the law of faith (Romans 3:21-27).
Some believe we are no longer under law but only under Grace. This is wrong.
We have always been under grace. In fact, salvation has always been by grace through faith. In that there is no difference between the New and the Old covenants. It is just that before Christ came the faith was in God that He would provide the Messiah. After Christ came and with His death, burial and resurrection the faith is in God that Jesus is the Messiah.
 
Wrong.
How could he have died under the new covenant when Jesus had not even ressurected from the dead?
Hebrews 9:16-17,
- for where a testament is there must also of necessity be the DEATH of the testator
- for a testament is IN FORCE AFTER MEN ARE DEAD, otherwise it is of no strength WHILE THE TESTATOR LIVETH


Jesus saved the thief while He was still alive,
- today you will be with Me in paradise(saved while Jesus was alive)

Therefore Jesus' new testament had not yet gone into force.
Also to be saved under the new covenant you must believe in the death, burial and ressurection of Christ.
The thief had not even witnessed Jesus' ressurection.
Jesus never required the thief to believe the new testament gospel.
The thief died during the old law of Moses while it was still in force.
John the Baptist was baptizing Jews during this time. John's baptism is under the old law.
Because JESUS Himself is the New Covenant and His Blood was being poured out before the FATHER while on the Cross

Furthermore, JESUS DIED on the Cross next to the thief who BELIEVED and JESUS Said "THIS DAY" you will be with ME in Paradise
 
I think Paul was referring to law, generally, where law refers to a code of conduct whereby one conducts and lives his life (See Romans 2:12-15)

And well they should, since to be saved by works was possible only if the law was obeyed perfectly with not a single transgression. But, of course, as Paul noted, no one has.

Those are not works of law, but rather obedience to the gospel.

I agree.

No, as I noted above, I think law refers to that code of conduct by which we live. Hearing, belief, repentance, confession and baptism are not a part of a code of conduct. They are conditions to which God honors His promises to give eternal life, i.e, salvation. We are under the law of faith (Romans 3:21-27).

We have always been under grace. In fact, salvation has always been by grace through faith. In that there is no difference between the New and the Old covenants. It is just that before Christ came the faith was in God that He would provide the Messiah. After Christ came and with His death, burial and resurrection the faith is in God that Jesus is the Messiah.
Thanks for the detailed explanation.

You dont believe the new testament gospel has works that are required by God for salvation.
You refer to these as obedience,
Those are not works of law, but rather obedience to the gospel
Sir, I suggest we define words with the same words the Holy Spirit chose in the new testament.
Obedience to the gospel is literally works of faith.

Faith which is essential to salvation is called a WORK by Jesus Himself,
John 6:28-29,
- ....this is the work of God that YOU believe on the one whom He sent

James teaches we are justified by works James 2:24, - justified by works and not by faith only

The believing, repenting, confessing, and living faithful are works of faith that we do.

No, as I noted above, I think law refers to that code of conduct by which we live. Hearing, belief, repentance, confession and baptism are not a part of a code of conduct. They are conditions to which God honors His promises to give eternal life, i.e, salvation. We are under the law of faith (Romans 3:21-27)
Yes they are under faith but faith has many uses in the new testament.
Faith can mean personal belief.
It can also mean the system of faith known as Christs new testament gospel.
This faith that all are under today is Christ's law!!!
Galatians 6:2,
- bear ye one another' burdens and so fulfill the law of Christ

Galatians 5:1,
- standfast therefore in the liberty(Christs new testament law) wherewith Christ has made us FREE and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage(old law, old covenant of Moses)

James 1:25,
- but whose looketh into the perfect law of liberty and continueth therein he being not a forgetful hearer but a DOER of the  word this man shall be blessed in his work
 
Last edited:
Because JESUS Himself is the New Covenant and His Blood was being poured out before the FATHER while on the Cross

Furthermore, JESUS DIED on the Cross next to the thief who BELIEVED and JESUS Said "THIS DAY" you will be with ME in Paradise
Jesus said, talked - you will be with Me in paradice while He was still alive!!! Impossible for the thief to be saved under the new covenant because it violates the conditions of Jesus' will and testament, Hebrews 9:16-17.
Your reasoning is unscriptual.
 
Jesus said, talked - you will be with Me in paradice while He was still alive!!! Impossible for the thief to be saved under the new covenant because it violates the conditions of Jesus' will and testament, Hebrews 9:16-17.
Your reasoning is unscriptual.
my Brother Titus

Paradise is where the souls of OT Saints went after they died.

JESUS went there to "take captive captivity" and bring them into Heaven as HE purchased them with HIS Blood.
 
my Brother Titus

Paradise is where the souls of OT Saints went after they died.

JESUS went there to "take captive captivity" and bring them into Heaven as HE purchased them with HIS Blood.
Yes but irrelevant to what covenant was in effect when the thief on the cross was saved by Jesus.
Violation of scripture will not allow your conclusion that the thief was saved under the new testament.

Every single person that Jesus saved while He was living on earth was saved while the old covenant was still in force, Hebrews 9:16-17.

Jesus was alive when He told the thief he was saved.
The thief was not saved after Jesus died. He was saved when Jesus said,
- today thou will be with Me in paradise

Jesus was alive when He forgave the sins of the paraliitc,
Matthew 9:2,
- and behold they brought to Jesus a man sick with the palsy lying on a bed and Jesus seeing their faith said unto the sick of the palsy son be of good cheer, thy sins are forgivin thee

Was Jesus alive or dead when He forgave this mans sins?
Was Jesus alive or dead when He forgave the sins of the thief on the cross?

I dont know too many dead people that say, - today you will be with Me in paradise

Did Jeeus save the thief on the cross when He was alive or dead?
Easy.
Only when Jesus was dead did His new will and testament go into effect, Hebrews 9:16-17.

Matthew 22:29
 
the law said stumble in one point
A born again Christian cannot sin, 1 John 3:9. I've been born again for 48 years and do not have any desire to break God's law, and it is the same for all who are actually born again. I am not unique in that promise. 1 John 3:5 And you know that He was manifested to take away our sins, and in Him there is no sin.
break one command (the wage of sin is death)
If you are breaking God's laws, you have not been born again of the Spirit and are still under the law.
 
It does not say we are unable to commit personal sin

it means we can not live in sin.
You are reading out of context. 1 John 3 is not about personal immaturities of the fruit of the Spirit, it is speaking of lawlessness, verse 4. The New Covenant is the laws of God written on our hearts to obey. We cannot commit those sins, 1 John 3:9. The word "practice" is not in the original but in the corrupted codices of Alexandria.

Now regarding those personal immaturities. Those are addressed in 2 Peter 1:5-11. Read to the end and you will see that the Author and Finisher of our faith CAN make you mature in ALL of them to where you "NEVER STUMBLE." Do you believe Jesus is doing this in you?
If you say you have no sin you decieve yourself

these are not my words
The key word is say. Look at 1 John 2:4 to see why this person is a liar. It is not because no one can stop sinning. It is someone who lies about the sins he knows he is committing. "4 He who says, “I know Him,” and does not keep His commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him. Stop being deceived by those who say we will never stop sinning until we die and receive new bodies. If that is what you belief, chuck it out the window! Jesus is more powerful than that if you let Him.
 
A born again Christian cannot sin, 1 John 3:9.
1,2,3, John is written to born again christians.

You need to re-read John's instruction as he writes down the revelation of the Holy Spirit.
1John 1:8-10,
- if we say we have no sin we decieve ourselves and the truth is not in us(born again christians)
- if we(born again christians) confess our sins Jesus is faithful and just to forgive us(born again Christians) and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness
 
Yes but irrelevant to what covenant was in effect when the thief on the cross was saved by Jesus.
Violation of scripture will not allow your conclusion that the thief was saved under the new testament.

Every single person that Jesus saved while He was living on earth was saved while the old covenant was still in force, Hebrews 9:16-17.

Jesus was alive when He told the thief he was saved.
The thief was not saved after Jesus died. He was saved when Jesus said,
- today thou will be with Me in paradise

Jesus was alive when He forgave the sins of the paraliitc,
Matthew 9:2,
- and behold they brought to Jesus a man sick with the palsy lying on a bed and Jesus seeing their faith said unto the sick of the palsy son be of good cheer, thy sins are forgivin thee

Was Jesus alive or dead when He forgave this mans sins?
Was Jesus alive or dead when He forgave the sins of the thief on the cross?

I dont know too many dead people that say, - today you will be with Me in paradise

Did Jeeus save the thief on the cross when He was alive or dead?
Easy.
Only when Jesus was dead did His new will and testament go into effect, Hebrews 9:16-17.

Matthew 22:29
Violation of scripture will not allow your conclusion that the thief was saved under the new testament.
Your me cracking up on this one!

JESUS, who is the New Covenant, is in violation of Scripture because of...............lol

Love you my Brother in Christ
 
Your me cracking up on this one!

JESUS, who is the New Covenant, is in violation of Scripture because of...............lol

Love you my Brother in Christ
You misunderstood. You either believe the word of God or you don't.
Hebrews 9:16-17,
- for where a testament is there must also of necessity be the death of the testator
- for a testament is in force AFTER men are dead otherwise it is of no strength while the testator liveth

Do you believe the thief on the cross was saved under Jesus' new will and testament?

Jesus lived under the old covenant. He enacted His new covenant in His death.
Galatians 4:4,
- but when the fullness of the time was come God sent forth His Son made of a women made UNDER THE LAW

To redeem them that were UNDER THE LAW (jews) that we might receive the adoption of sons

Jesus' earthly ministry was during the time of the old covenant.
 
You misunderstood. You either believe the word of God or you don't.
Hebrews 9:16-17,
- for where a testament is there must also of necessity be the death of the testator
- for a testament is in force AFTER men are dead otherwise it is of no strength while the testator liveth

Do you believe the thief on the cross was saved under Jesus' new will and testament?

Jesus lived under the old covenant. He enacted His new covenant in His death.
Galatians 4:4,
- but when the fullness of the time was come God sent forth His Son made of a women made UNDER THE LAW

To redeem them that were UNDER THE LAW (jews) that we might receive the adoption of sons

Jesus' earthly ministry was during the time of the old covenant.
Do you believe the thief on the cross was saved under Jesus' new will and testament?
In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God.

In the Volume of the Book(Scriptures)
it is written of ME

One Wiser then Solomon is HERE

the son of Man is LORD of the Sabbath


One GREATER then the Temple is HERE

Destroy this temple and in 3 days I will RAISE IT UP

“If you knew the gift of God and who is asking you for a drink, you would have asked Him, and He would have given you living water.”

How long have I been with you, If you have seen ME, you have seen the FATHER


IAM, the Resurrection and the LIFE

Lazarus, Come forth!!!

Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God: and they that hear shall live.

This is what the Sovereign LORD, the Holy One of Israel, says


SHALOM
 
Last edited:
In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God.

In the Volume of the Book(Scriptures)
it is written of ME

One Wiser then Solomon is HERE

the son of Man is LORD of the Sabbath


One GREATER then the Temple is HERE

Destroy this temple and in 3 days I will RAISE IT UP

“If you knew the gift of God and who is asking you for a drink, you would have asked Him, and He would have given you living water.”

How long have I been with you, If you have seen ME, you have seen the FATHER


IAM, the Resurrection and the LIFE

Lazarus, Come forth!!!

Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God: and they that hear shall live.

This is what the Sovereign LORD, the Holy One of Israel, says.........all of the above and more!!!


SHALOM
Matthew 22:29
 
1,2,3, John is written to born again christians.

You need to re-read John's instruction as he writes down the revelation of the Holy Spirit.
1John 1:8-10,
- if we say we have no sin we decieve ourselves and the truth is not in us(born again christians)
- if we(born again christians) confess our sins Jesus is faithful and just to forgive us(born again Christians) and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness
1 John 1:5-10 is the Semitic writing style of synonym parallelism, but of contrasts as opposed to saying the same thing twice in two different forms like Acts 4:33. There it shows that grace is power. Not a license to sin.

In 1 John 1:5-10 these verses are contrasts of Light vs. Darkness.

5: God is light
6: If we walk in darkness
7: If we walk in the light

8: if you say you are in the light but are in darkness - that is the lie.
9: How to become a Christian and be cleansed of all unrighteousness
10: If you say you were born without sin you lie.

2:1 I write this so you will not sin. Titus, Why would John say that if it was impossible? The doctrine that we will always sin until we die and receive new bodies as it seems you've swallowed is a doctrine of demons. They want you to think of yourself as a sinner, because "as a man thinks in his heart, so is he." I know the truth, and thus don't commit sins. I go to bed each night with a clear conscience as Paul taught us and claimed for himself. 1 John 3:21-22 and 100% of my prayers have been answered, sometimes immediately.

Don't drink the poison!
 
Thanks for the detailed explanation.

You dont believe the new testament gospel has works that are required by God for salvation.
You refer to these as obedience,

Sir, I suggest we define words with the same words the Holy Spirit chose in the new testament.
Obedience to the gospel is literally works of faith.
Hearing, believing, confessing and being baptized are all conditions for being saved, i.e., being justified, regenerated and initially sanctified. These are works but not works of law as in the sense of a code of conduct for living. Faithful living is a work in the sense of a code of conduct, and I put it in the category of the law of Christ. But be careful. It is not a condition for being saved, nor is a condition for staying saved. We are saved by grace through faith and we stay saved by grace through faith. Making faithful living a condition for salvation is a problem that arose in the churches of Galatia and is often referred to as Galatianism. It is a problem that Paul addressed in his letter to them. Specifically in chapter three:

Gal 3:1 O foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you? It was before your eyes that Jesus Christ was publicly portrayed as crucified. 2 Let me ask you only this: Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law or by hearing with faith? : Are you so foolish? Having begun by the Spirit, are you now being perfected by the flesh?

The problem is rampant in Christendom today. I witnessed it with my own dear mother on her death bed. Our young preacher was with us, and he asked, "Are you afraid?" and she answered "Yes". It bothered me then, but I didn't know why, exactly. But it was clear that she was afraid that she might not have been "good enough". I only wish that I had known then what I know now and I could have reassured her. Assurance of salvation is, I believe, an important aspect of our belief system that is not well addressed today.

If the final judgment were held at this very moment, would you be saved?” Assurance of salvation is the ability to answer “Yes!” to this question, rather than to respond with an ambiguous “Maybe”; “I hope so, but I’m not really sure”; “I don’t know.” How we answer this question obviously makes a world of difference concerning our happiness and peace of mind during this life. Our greatest conscious need is for a feeling of confidence regarding our present acceptance with God and our future participation in heaven. We need “blessed assurance,” assurance of salvation. The good news is that such assurance is here for us. Indeed, it is the natural result of a proper understanding of grace, especially of the key concept of justification by faith. Every Christian should have this assurance.

But that is perhaps for another thread.
Faith which is essential to salvation is called a WORK by Jesus Himself,
John 6:28-29,
- ....this is the work of God that YOU believe on the one whom He sent

James teaches we are justified by works James 2:24, - justified by works and not by faith only
Yes, but we have to be careful with the words here. James is not saying that faith plus works as necessary for salvation. If you read his letter carefully, what he is advocating is for a faith that works.

This understanding helps us to understand how a Christian can be both justified by faith and judged by works. That we will be judged by works is a truth taught throughout Scripture. For example, Jer 17:10 says, “I, the LORD, search the heart, I test the mind, even to give to each man according to his ways, according to the results of his deeds.” Jesus says in Matt 16:27, “For the Son of Man is going to come in the glory of His Father and with His angels, and will then repay every man according to his deeds.” He declares in Rev 22:12, “Behold, I am coming quickly, and My reward is with Me, to render to every man according to what he has done.” That this includes the saved and the unsaved alike is clear from 2 Cor 5:10, “For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each one may be recompensed for his deeds in the body, according to what he has done, whether good or bad.” Surely one reason why Christians will be judged according to their works, both good and bad, is to determine the degree of reward to be received by each. But another reason for exposing all our works on the day of judgment will be to demonstrate the presence or absence of the faith which justifies. Such an examination is not necessary for God’s own sake, but it will be done in order to demonstrate that God’s judgment is impartial or without favoritism, that he is no “respecter of persons” (Acts 10:34-35; Rom 2:6,11; Eph 6:8-9; Col 3:25; 1 Pet 1:17).
The believing, repenting, confessing, and living faithful are works of faith that we do.

Yes they are under faith but faith has many uses in the new testament.
Faith can mean personal belief.
It can also mean the system of faith known as Christs new testament gospel.
This faith that all are under today is Christ's law!!!
Galatians 6:2,
- bear ye one another' burdens and so fulfill the law of Christ
I agree. However, I do so with the caveat concerning the Galatianism I posted above.
Galatians 5:1,
- standfast therefore in the liberty(Christs new testament law) wherewith Christ has made us FREE and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage(old law, old covenant of Moses)

James 1:25,
- but whose looketh into the perfect law of liberty and continueth therein he being not a forgetful hearer but a DOER of the  word this man shall be blessed in his work
Again I agree but stay clear of professing any hint of Galatianism.
 
Back
Top Bottom