The Trinity study ,plural references to God in the Old Testament:Plural nouns, pronouns, verbs, adverbs

[Capbook]

Correct. Only the Father forgives sins in heaven. That's what we are saying. You seem to be catching on.

Runningman, your statements seems inconsistent, in your Post#395, below was what you said;

"Blasphemy against the Son is forgivable, blasphemy against the Spirit (the Spirit is the Father according to John 4:23,24) is not forgivable."

This reply, you believe the Father forgive sins, but in your Post#395, do not forgive.

Care enough to explain?

 

[Runningman]

Runningman, your statements seems inconsistent, in your Post#395, below was what you said;

"Blasphemy against the Son is forgivable, blasphemy against the Spirit (the Spirit is the Father according to John 4:23,24) is not forgivable."

This reply, you believe the Father forgive sins, but in your Post#395, do not forgive.

Care enough to explain?

Yes, but blasphemy against the Spirit (the Spirit is the Father according to John 4:23,24) is not forgivable. I don't see any inconsistency in what Jesus said. Generally speaking, the Father forgives sins, but about this specific sin He does not.

 

[Capbook]

Yes, but blasphemy against the Spirit (the Spirit is the Father according to John 4:23,24) is not forgivable. I don't see any inconsistency in what Jesus said. Generally speaking, the Father forgives sins, but about this specific sin He does not.

Ok, as the Father forgive those that blaspheme Him, but the Holy Spirit do not, are they the same person with same will?

The word "blasphemes" with Strong#G987, in Greek "βλασφημέω blasphēmeō" Bible lexicon defined it as means - to speak of God or divine things in terms of impious irreverence, to blaspheme.

Thus, with Bible lexicon definition it proves the God's nature of the Holy Spirit as "blasphemes" means to speak impious irreverence to God.

Luke 12:10 "R1And everyoneG3956 whoG3739 N1speaksG3004 a wordG3056 againstG1519 the SonG5207 of ManG444, it will be forgivenG863 him; but he who blasphemesG987 againstG1519 the HolyG40 SpiritG4151, it will not be forgivenG863 him.
G987
βλασφημέω blasphēmeō
34x: to defame, revile, slander, Mat_27:39; to speak of God or divine things in terms of impious irreverence, to blaspheme, Mat_9:3; Mat_26:65.

 

[Runningman]

Ok, as the Father forgive those that blaspheme Him, but the Holy Spirit do not, are they the same person with same will?

The word "blasphemes" with Strong#G987, in Greek "βλασφημέω blasphēmeō" Bible lexicon defined it as means - to speak of God or divine things in terms of impious irreverence, to blaspheme.

Thus, with Bible lexicon definition it proves the God's nature of the Holy Spirit as "blasphemes" means to speak impious irreverence to God.

Luke 12:10 "R1And everyoneG3956 whoG3739 N1speaksG3004 a wordG3056 againstG1519 the SonG5207 of ManG444, it will be forgivenG863 him; but he who blasphemesG987 againstG1519 the HolyG40 SpiritG4151, it will not be forgivenG863 him.
G987
βλασφημέω blasphēmeō
34x: to defame, revile, slander, Mat_27:39; to speak of God or divine things in terms of impious irreverence, to blaspheme, Mat_9:3; Mat_26:65.

Not sure where you got the idea "as the Father forgive those that blaspheme Him" since the Bible never says that. To early Christians, there was no third person in a trinity known as a Holy Spirit. There was the Father only, who they knew as the Spirit or Holy Spirit. Binitarianism developed later as a sectarian movement. The early proto-trinitarians were not orthodox either. The Holy Spirit you think is a third person was not developed until the later 4th century at the council of Constantinople and that is when trinitarianism was official created. The earliest Jesus-taught view of God is Unitarian, strictly monotheistic.