I did my MA Theology thesis on Rom 1:18-2:1 as a juridical parable, so I had some ideas from that process.Do you see any other juridical parables in the Jewish scriptures besides 2 Sam 12? ChatGPT (becoming a close friend of mine) also notes 2 Sam 12 as an example of a juridical parable but gives no other examples. It also notes that Rom. 1:18-32 lacks some of the characteristics of a juridical parable. I am not saying it is not a juridical parable. I am simply noting what ChatGPT says.
Some say 2 Sam 14 presents a juridical parable. I briefly had noted "In 2 Samuel 14, David was asked to avoid prosecution of his son Absalom who had murdered his brother. The passage has legal issues which are not about David’s guilt. Thus, 2 Samuel 14 presents an unusual juridical parable."
Even less so is Isa 5 considered one. The juridical parable term may be applied too widely. Isaiah 5 has been described as leading people to judgment only to show the text is talking about them. So far I have not been convinced of that. The best juridical parables use the force of judgment of the parable content to be turned back on the guilty party.
It is nice with AI that some ideas can be examined without having to figure out where the info will be.
It is interesting and helpful to share that you looked at 1:18-32 as possibly applying to Israel. I had not found anyone else evaluating the text as being about Israel's history. Just this summer I have written out more detail about 1:18-32 being a better match to Israel history than to gentiles. Romans 2:1 then exposes the gentiles' judgmental attitude while applying Rom 1:18-32 to their fleshly behavior in addition to exposing the judgmental attitude. It is 22k words to show this and to express how well it fits the pattern of 2 Sam 12, but adapted to a letter, where the reaction of the gentile audience would have been anticipated by Paul.I have also wrestled with the idea that Rom. 1:18-32 is a commentary on Israel's failure and exile, but I think the text better first a description of Roman culture, particularly Nero's propensity for theatrics in his personal life.
Last edited: