I would say that we are all born sinners with sinful natures. And unless God intervenes we stay that way. Humanity is totally depraved; and our sinful nature affects every part of us.
They are all gone aside, they have all together become filthy; there is none that does good or right, no, not one.
Ps 14:3
Surely there is
not a
righteous man upon earth who does good and never sins. Eccles 7:20
I hold to the view the view that all people inherit from Adam a sinful nature, not his guilt. That we are not guilty of sin until we start practicing sin in our lives. And I think that varies from person to person.
My thought is that sinning flows inevitably from one’s corrupted human nature. Human nature after the fall of Adam can only sin because the fall corrupted human nature.
I like the way Joel R. Beeke puts it.
Total depravity thus entails moral inability. In ourselves, we are unable to do anything about our condition. We are spiritually impotent by nature, unable and unwilling to save ourselves. We cannot appreciate the Christian faith and we are powerless to work toward our conversion. “We can do nothing but sin,” Calvin says, “until the Holy Spirit forms a new will within us.” No matter how much the natural man is urged by the law or the gospel to believe in Christ and turn from sin, he is “not able, by his own strength. to convert himself, or to prepare himself thereunto” (Westminster Confession, 9.3).
Charles Hodge puts it poignantly: “The rejection of the gospel is as clear proof of moral depravity as inability to see the sun at noon is proof of blindness.” The natural man may want to be free of some sin and of the consequences of sin; he may even expend some effort in that direction. But he is too much a slave to it. He is not simply “going lost” or “dying,” he is lost and is dead in trespasses and sins (Eph. 2:1).
Every person in the world is by nature a slave of sin. The world, by nature, is held in sin’s grip. What a shock to our complacency—that everything of us by nature belongs to sin. Our silences belong to sin, our omissions belong to sin, our talents belong to sin, our actions belong to sin. Every facet of our personalities belongs to sin; it owns us and dominates us. We are its servants.
Total depravity is active in us. It is not simply the absence of righteousness, but the presence of corruption. Our depravity is enormously creative and inventive, ever devising new ways of violating God’s will. It is a growing cancer within us—a rampant, productive, energetic, and self-propagating entity. It is fire out of control—a living, fierce, powerful force. In the horrors of the Holocaust, the monstrosity of modern-day terrorism, and the dreadful headlines of our daily newspapers, we are shown what our corrupt, active human nature is capable of, given the requisite conditions, if God leaves us to ourselves.
Joel R. Beeke, Living for God’s Glory