civic
Active Member
This from AI
The idea that Calvinism makes God a narcissist creating vessels of wrath for destruction is a common criticism, stemming from the doctrine of predestination, where God sovereignly chooses some for salvation (vessels of mercy) and leaves others to their sin (vessels of wrath) to display His justice and glory. While Calvinists assert God's glory requires revealing His attributes, including wrath, through the damned (Romans 9), critics argue this portrays God as unjust, tyrannical, or even the author of evil, contrasting it with Jesus's humble, other-directed nature. Defenders counter that God's glory isn't selfish narcissism but His inherent, perfect nature, and that His decree of reprobation is a passive "passing over," not an active creation of evil, serving His greater good.
The Criticism: God as Narcissist/Tyrant
Critics argue that the God described in Calvinist theology meets the criteria for Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) as defined by the DSM-5.
1. The Argument for It Being Unloving
Critics argue that if God creates individuals knowing and decreeing their eternal destruction for His own glory, it contradicts the biblical assertion that "God is love" (1 John 4:8).
lets discuss
The idea that Calvinism makes God a narcissist creating vessels of wrath for destruction is a common criticism, stemming from the doctrine of predestination, where God sovereignly chooses some for salvation (vessels of mercy) and leaves others to their sin (vessels of wrath) to display His justice and glory. While Calvinists assert God's glory requires revealing His attributes, including wrath, through the damned (Romans 9), critics argue this portrays God as unjust, tyrannical, or even the author of evil, contrasting it with Jesus's humble, other-directed nature. Defenders counter that God's glory isn't selfish narcissism but His inherent, perfect nature, and that His decree of reprobation is a passive "passing over," not an active creation of evil, serving His greater good.
The Criticism: God as Narcissist/Tyrant
- Rigging the Game: Critics suggest God preordains everything, rigging history so people have no real choice, all to praise Himself, making Him seem like a self-centered "It's all about me" figure.
- Author of Evil: Some argue that by ordaining sin and damnation, God becomes the ultimate cause of evil, a "moral monster" or "tyrant".
- Unjust Damnation: How can God be just punishing those He foreordained for destruction, especially when He knew they'd end up damned but created them anyway
- God's Character vs. Human Understanding: The debate hinges on whether God's sovereign plan, focused on His glory, aligns with human concepts of justice, love, and fairness, with differing views on whether God causes sin or merely permits it for His higher purposes
Critics argue that the God described in Calvinist theology meets the criteria for Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) as defined by the DSM-5.
- Lack of Empathy: Critics claim that creating individuals specifically for destruction ("vessels of wrath") demonstrates a lack of empathy, treating humans as mere objects to "show off" divine power.
- Grandiose Self-Importance: The biblical God's insistence on constant praise and the belief that the entire universe exists solely for His glory are seen by skeptics as hallmarks of grandiosity and an "appetite for applause".
- Human-centric Narcissism: Some philosophers argue that any concept of God is inherently narcissistic because it presumes that an all-powerful creator would be "petty" enough to care about minute human behaviors
1. The Argument for It Being Unloving
Critics argue that if God creates individuals knowing and decreeing their eternal destruction for His own glory, it contradicts the biblical assertion that "God is love" (1 John 4:8).
- Lack of Redemptive Purpose: Some theologians argue that wrath and judgment can only be seen as "loving" if they serve a redemptive or corrective purpose; eternal destruction without hope for restoration appears purely punitive.
- Predestined Despair: Critics of "double predestination" (the idea that God actively chooses who to damn) argue it makes the gospel "bad news" for the majority of humanity, portraying God as a deterministic "puppet master" rather than a loving father.
lets discuss
