The argument was he was baptized en the spirit
That is a proven fact
Acts 11:15–16 (NET 2nd ed.) — 15 Then as I began to speak, the Holy Spirit fell on them just as he did on us at the beginning. 16 And I remembered the word of the Lord, as he used to say, ‘John baptized with water, but you will be baptized with the Holy Spirit.’
No Cornelius did not receive the same promise as the apostles from Jesus.
Acts 11:15-16,
- then as I began to speak
the Holy Spirit fell on them just as he did on us at the beginning
The similarity Peter notes is both events required no man laying on the hands.
Cornelius' miraculous gift is the ONLY example of someone receiving the Spirit directly just as the apostles received Him.
So Cornelius is the exception not the norm.
Every single other account you have an apostle lay their hands on them to receive the Spirit.
That is what Peter is saying here.
- then as I began to speak the Holy Spirit fell on them just as he did on us at the beginning
Acts 11:15-16,
- then I remembered the word of the Lord how that He said, John indeed baptized with water but ye shall be baptized with the Holy Spirit
You need to include the next verse to understand why Peter made this statement.
Verse 17,
- forasmuch then as God gave them
the like gift as He did unto us who believed on the Lord Jesus Christ what was I that I could withstand God
Peter is seeing this miracle take place with Cornelius and it occurs just like His experience by the Holy Spirit coming on them. Peter knows this is different because Acts 8 had people needing the hands of Peter laid on them to receive the gifts of the Spirit.
But also Peter notes that Cornelius received the the
like gift as he did to Peter and the rest of the apostles at the very beginning.
The like gift is not the promise of Holy Spirit baptism that the apostles received.
It is the like or same exact gift the apostles were given the moment they were Holy Spirit baptized.
That gift being tongue speaking.
Acts 10:45-46 and Acts 2:3-4
- and they of the circumcision which believed were astonished as many as came with Peter because that on the gentiles also was
poured out the GIFT of the Holy Spirit
- for they heard them
speak with tongues...
- and there appeared unto them cloven tongues like as of fire and it sat upon each of them
- and they were all
filled with the Holy Spirit and began to speak in tongues...
You ignore that only the apostles were promised Holy Spirit baptism.
You ignore the qualifications that had to be met in order to receive what the apostles received.
For example an eye witness to Jesus after His ressurection.
They had to be in Jerusalem on penetcost.
They had to be baptized by John as that is who John spoke to who would receive Jesus baptizing them with the Spirit.
Off topic.
Peter plainly said what saved Cornelius and it wasn't the miraculous working of the Holy Spirit falling on him to speak in tongues.
If tongue speaking is how you know Cornelius was saved, then where's your tongue speaking?
You were not even saved the way you claim Cornelius was saved!!! You did not get what Cornelius got.
Acts 11:14,
- who shall tell thee
words whereby thou and all thy house shall be saved
Peter said Cornelius was saved by hearing Peter preach the gospel, so the word of God saved him.
Not once does Peter make reference to the Holy Spirit falling on Peter as what saved him.
Dont you think Peter would teach what you teach instead of saying nothing about the miraculous event that occurred with Cornelius when Peter did say what saved Cornelius?
When we know why the apostles received the baptism of the Holy Spirit we can better understand why Cornelius did not receive the same promise and power the apostles received.
This outpouring of the Spirit on the apostles was to enable them to accomplish the task the Lord had given them.
Cornelius was never given this work.
John 14:16,
- and I will pray the Father and He shall give you the Comforter that He may abide with you for ever
- but the Comforter which is the Holy Spirit whom the Father will send in My name He shall teach you all things and bring to your remembrance whatsoever I have said unto you
The baptism of the Holy Spirit was performed by Christ on the apostles to enable them to reveal the whole truth with the accompanying evidence that it came from Deity.
Having been promised to no others and to be given for no other purpose than has been demonstrated one would have to conclude that the house of Cornelius was not given the Holy Spirit for the same reason.
No Bibles therefore miraculous knowledge was given to the apostles through the baptism of the Spirit.
This they had to have in order to fullfil the commandment to preach the gospel to all nations, Matthew 28:19.
Cornelius was never commanded to go into all the world and preach the gospel.
Therefore he had no need to be given the Comforter as the apostles were given.
Only way people who heard the preaching of the apostles knew that they were spokesmen from God was by their perfect memory of all of Jesus' teaching and their performing of miracles that confirmed the word was from God.
Cornelius needed none of these.
He only was given the Holy Spirit to give a sign to the Jews so that they could know the gentiles had been excepted by God into the kingdom.
This is the purpose of Cornelius' miraculous tongue speaking.
It was not to save him but a sign for the jews.
Mark 16:15-20,
- So then after the Lord has spoken unto them(apostles) Jesus was received up into heaven and sat on the right hand of God
- and they(apostles) went forth and preached every where the Lord working with them and CONFIRMING the word with
signs(miracles) following
Anyone who claims Holy Spirit baptism today must perform miracles as CONFIRMING they are Holy men of God.
Never in all the new testament was Holy Spirit baptism not accompanied with miraculous gifts of those who truly received God.
All those today who claim it. Can only make empty claims with their mouths. They cannot confirm it as did the apostles.
Paul being Holy Spirit baptized preached with demonstration of the Holy Spirit.
That is proof not merely saying you have it.
1Corinthians 2:4,
- and my speech and my preaching was not with enticing words of mans wisdom but in
demonstration of the Spirit and of power