The context of the Eucharist from Passover Seder : sacrifice, real presence, priest, unblemished lamb

[TomL]

As long as it is a Catholic offering?

??? Not my view

 

[FreeInChrist]

??? Not my view

You said

TomL said:
I am not saying it; Catholic doctrine teaches Christ is present in every offering everywhere and forever the Eucharist is offered.

I replied

As long as it is a Catholic offering?

Because the Catholics in the family will insist any that is not of a Catholic offering is wrong.

 

[TomL]

You said

TomL said:
I am not saying it; Catholic doctrine teaches Christ is present in every offering everywhere and forever the Eucharist is offered.

I replied

Because the Catholics in the family will insist any that is not of a Catholic offering is wrong.

Well, I would disagree with the Catholic view.

 

[mikepec]

You said

TomL said:
I am not saying it; Catholic doctrine teaches Christ is present in every offering everywhere and forever the Eucharist is offered.

I replied

Because the Catholics in the family will insist any that is not of a Catholic offering is wrong.

Because that is what Christ taught John, John taught his disciples, as bishops in succession to present day.
Their writings confirm it.

Indeed the Protestant Eucharist is heretical, and profaning the Eucharist and Christ.

That is what Christ taught. You are either for him or against Him.

You cannot make up your own doctrine.

That is what the pillar of truth the true church teaches with the certainty of the power to bind and lose.

 

[FreeInChrist]

Well, I would disagree with the Catholic view.

LOL... I do too and the last convo I had with a family member, the following visit he asked if I still was on that forum I am on
and I said yes, and he told me I better stop because it is dangerous..... LOL

And that was because I knocked that Catholic view and some other things.

 

[FreeInChrist]

Because that is what Christ taught John, John taught his disciples, as bishops in succession to present day.
Their writings confirm it.

Indeed the Protestant Eucharist is heretical, and profaning the Eucharist and Christ.

That is what Christ taught.You are either for him or agaibst Him.

You cannot make up your own doctrine,

That is what the pillar of truth the true church teaches with the certainty of the power to bind and lose.

To believe that a wafer and sip of juice does not become body and blood is a heretical doctrine?

Well.

We partake of both elements, wear as the local Catholic churches only serve the wafers. They keep the wine for the priests.

1 Cor 11
And Jesus said... This do, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of Me." 26 For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death till He comes.

My goodness.... I better stop immediately? I was only doing what Jesus said to.

 

[TomL]

LOL... I do too and the last convo I had with a family member, the following visit he asked if I still was on that forum I am on
and I said yes, and he told me I better stop because it is dangerous..... LOL

And that was because I knocked that Catholic view and some other things.

Oh, ok.

 

[TomL]

Because that is what Christ taught John, John taught his disciples, as bishops in succession to present day.
Their writings confirm it.

Indeed the Protestant Eucharist is heretical, and profaning the Eucharist and Christ.

That is what Christ taught. You are either for him or against Him.

You cannot make up your own doctrine.

That is what the pillar of truth the true church teaches with the certainty of the power to bind and lose.

I will have to disagree with you

Christ is in heaven, and I know of no one capable of calling him down at various times.

 

[Eternally-Grateful]

Because that is what Christ taught John, John taught his disciples, as bishops in succession to present day.
Their writings confirm it.

Indeed the Protestant Eucharist is heretical, and profaning the Eucharist and Christ.

That is what Christ taught. You are either for him or against Him.

You cannot make up your own doctrine.

That is what the pillar of truth the true church teaches with the certainty of the power to bind and lose.

John taught what Jesus taught.

whoever eats this food. which endures forever. This bread from heaven, this flesh and blood that Jesus came to give will

never hunger
Never thirst
Live forever
Never die
Never be lost
Has eternal life
Will be raised on the last day
Will live as long as he lives (he will never die)
John 6

So what the catholic church teaches concerning the eucharist never originated with john.

 

[TomL]

Because that is what Christ taught John, John taught his disciples, as bishops in succession to present day.
Their writings confirm it.

Indeed the Protestant Eucharist is heretical, and profaning the Eucharist and Christ.

That is what Christ taught. You are either for him or against Him.

You cannot make up your own doctrine.

That is what the pillar of truth the true church teaches with the certainty of the power to bind and lose.

Um, nowhere did Christ teach he could be called down from heaven after his resurrection and his body be found in a wafer and his blood in wine.