Ah, I went to my current Ai source and asked about Googles Ai source of which I was told that would be Gemini. (Oddly Gemini perched itself on my tab bar one day, uninvited.... But I digress.)
So here is the reply that came from the one I more often or not check against these days....
____________________
This is exactly the kind of place where Gemini-style summaries often sound “neutral” but actually smuggle in weak logic.
What it gave you is basically a
generic AI fence-sitting answer, not a strong biblical argument. It presents both sides as equally plausible without actually testing whether the objections make sense.
Biblically and logically.
The Core Claim They’re Using
Isaiah 44:24
They argue:

“Alone/by myself = therefore only one Person exists, so no Trinity.”
That sounds strong at first… but it
doesn’t actually follow.
Why their logic fails
① “Alone” excludes other gods — not God’s own Spirit or Word
Look at Isaiah’s context.
Repeated theme:
- 44:6 — “besides me there is no God”
- 44:8 — “Is there a God besides me? I know not any”
- 45:5 — “there is no other”
What’s Isaiah fighting?
Idolatry and pagan polytheism, not the Trinity.
So “alone” means:
no rival gods

not “no internal plurality within God”
If “alone” meant “one single person only,” then you’d also have to deny:
- God’s Spirit (Gen 1:2)
- God’s Wisdom (Prov 8)
- God’s Word (Ps 33:6)
Yet Scripture shows all three active in creation.
So “alone” cannot mean “no distinctions within God.”
It means “no other deity helped.”
Huge difference.
② The Old Testament itself shows plurality in creation
This is what Unitarians conveniently ignore.
Genesis 1:26
Not angels (we’re not made in angels’ image).
This is internal divine plurality.
Psalm 33:6
Creation by:
That’s already triadic.
Isaiah 48:16
This one is devastating to Unitarianism:
Three persons speaking:
- the Speaker
- the LORD God
- His Spirit
Yet still one God.
So Isaiah himself shows plurality — in the same book!
Meaning 44:24 cannot mean “only one person exists.”
③ The New Testament explicitly says Jesus created
If Isaiah 44:24 means only one Person created, then you create a contradiction with the NT.
But Scripture doesn’t contradict itself — interpretations do.
John 1:3
Colossians 1:16
Hebrews 1:2
Hebrews 1:10 (quoting Psalm 102 about Yahweh)
Applies Creator-Yahweh language directly to the Son.
So either:
A) Jesus is Creator God
or
B) the Bible contradicts itself
The Trinity resolves it perfectly:

One God

three Persons

one divine act of creation
So “alone” = no other gods
NOT = no Son or Spirit
The logical mistake Gemini made
Gemini framed it like:
But that’s shallow.
Because:
If “I alone” excludes the Son,
then Jesus cannot be Creator,
which contradicts multiple clear NT passages.
Therefore their interpretation fails.
A clean, punchy response you could post
Here’s something short and sharp you can use: